This mystery-box series is strange, confusing, and messy—which is exactly why fans are hooked.

<img src="https://compote.slate.com/images/4fa63ac5-a311-47fe-8fe2-d99128fae8e2.jpeg?crop=1560,1040,x0,y0" title="The Lost-esque Horror Show That’s Becoming an Unlikely Hit” /> 

By